Shared memories of event details in the human brain are altered by misinformation and test expectations

by Xuhao Shao, Chuansheng Chen, Elizabeth F. Loftus, Bi Zhu

Shared memories of event details are crucial to eyewitness testimony. When different people encode or recall the same event, similar scene-specific neural activity patterns emerge across individual brains. However, it remains unclear whether these patterns are specific to event details and how test expectancy (i.e., expecting free recall or general memory tests) and misinformation affect them. In this study, 100 participants were randomly assigned to view one of two versions of each event. Both versions featured identical scenarios, but with different details. About half of the participants were informed about the upcoming free recall before viewing events, while the others were told to expect a general memory test. Functional magnetic resonance imaging was used to record their brain activity during four stages: viewing original events, initial free recall, reading misinformation, and final free recall of original events. The neuroimaging data were analyzed based on the similarity of neural patterns across participants. Test expectancy increased the similarity of detail-specific neural activity patterns between individuals when they viewed original events in brain regions relevant for visual attention. Misinformation increased the likelihood of people forming shared false memories of event details. People who formed shared false memories exhibited similar detail-specific patterns of activity in the dorsomedial prefrontal cortex when reading misinformation. People who formed shared true memories exhibited similar detail-specific patterns of activity in the inferior parietal lobe when viewing original events, as well as in the ventrolateral prefrontal cortex and middle temporal gyrus when recalling them after exposure to misinformation. Our findings revealed that different brain regions of the default mode network play distinct roles in the encoding and recall of event details shared by individuals.